My love of The Lord of The Rings is well known in these parts, but really my love goes beyond that trilogy to all things set in Tolkien's Middle Earth. I may have mentioned this before, but I cried a ridiculous amount when I first finished reading Return of The King, but that is nothing compared to how much I cried when I finished read the appendices to that book – it was like a close family member had died, and I couldn't be consoled. After that, I only wanted more and so I braved The Silmarillion.
I mention this because sometimes I feel like I'm not the right person to recommend things to people. I don't like things; I FUCKING LOVE THINGS. For example, I recommend show "Elementary" to some people, but as I'm already a huge fan of anything Sherlock Holmes, plus a sucker for procedural dramas, and I love both Lucy Liu and Jonny Lee Miller, was there any way I wasn't going to at least like it? And since I am the perfect audience, I'm not sure if other people will enjoy it like I do. It's much the same with The Hobbit. I love the universe so much, it would have been very hard to make something that I didn't enjoy. And I have always trusted Peter Jackson's decisions with these adaptations, so please keep that in mind when reading...
As anyone who has read both The Hobbit and The Lord of The Rings knows, much of what happens "off screen" in The Hobbit is retconed during the "The Counsel of Elrond" chapter (which is like a million pages long in Fellowship) and in the appendices of The Lord of The Rings – Ganalf explains where he was for a quarter of the book, Thorin's back story and name are explained, nameless characters and places get proper names, etc. So, that's what Peter Jackson has done – he's taking the information we find out later and filled in the blanks. And if anyone was wondering, like I was when I first heard, how this could be 3 movies, well there's your answer.
A final thought before I cut for spoilers: I initially wanted to see The Hobbit in standard, old school 2D. Fiancé was skeptical of the HFR, I don't like 3D, and last time we saw a 3D IMAX film (Promethus), I had to run out of the theater violently ill with a migraine. However, we accidentally bought tickets to the 3D IMAX version (or "IMAX" since it wasn't on a larger screen). Unlike other 3D movies I've seen, I did not get sick, or even get a headache. I felt immersed, not hit over the head with in-your-face gags. Most reviews I've read so far are complaining about the frame rate, NOT the film itself. And that's a bummer because I think those things should be looked at independently...
Alright, now on to the spoilery review, in list format because it really is just a jumble of thoughts...